Skip to main content

Mastery Criterion

The learning procedure requires three evidence conditions before recording mastery. Scores depend on the corpus, grader and verification method; they are not an independent measurement merely because a number was recorded.

The 3 conditions​

Condition 1 — Grade gate​

learn-grade produces:

  • overall_score (0.0–1.0)
  • misconceptions_absent (0.0 or 1.0)

Both must satisfy:

overall_score ≥ 0.7 AND misconceptions_absent == 1.0

A score of 0.8 with an unresolved misconception is not mastery.

Condition 2 — Transfer gate​

Two novel transfer problems (problems the learner has never seen before, in a different context than the original learning) must be solved at ≥ 0.7 each.

Condition 3 — Retention gate​

A spaced retrieval check via learn-retain must pass at ≥ 24 hours after the initial mastery claim.

Why all three?​

  • Grade gate — measures explanation quality and misconception absence
  • Transfer gate — measures ability to apply knowledge in new contexts (true understanding)
  • Retention gate — measures durability (not just cramming)

PFA mastery update​

The learner model uses the PFA (Performance Factors Analysis) update rule:

mastery_new = mastery_old + 0.3 × (score - mastery_old)

Applied at ≥ 5 observations per concept.

Evidence limits​

The skill procedure requires sycophancy screening with the available checker or its manual fallback. Persistence alone does not enforce that instruction or establish a distinct grader. Retain the corpus, grader identity, timestamps and transfer verification. See Anti-Sycophancy.